Sunday, March 27, 2011

Freedom of Information and the Civil Society ETL 523

As I read in Schauder’s paper about the civil society and the role that libraries play in the free flow of information and ideas I had a number of responses (Schauder, D. (2006). Libraries, ICT policy, and Australian civil society: isues and prospects from national consultations. Paper presented at the VALA 2006: Connecting with users. 13th biennial conference and exhibition 8-10 February 2006 Crown Towers, Melbourne, Australia. Conference proceedings. Retrieved from
http://www.valaconf.org.au/vala2006/papers2006/50 Schauder Final.pdf.

The civil society is certainly to be promoted and the role of libraries in the process needs to be recognised and encouraged. The notion of e-democracy, where citizens are able to vote on any and every issue is both one of Athenian utopianism and science fiction intrigue. The male Athenians could indulge in this practice because they had slaves and the female members of their households to attend to their other affairs. Science fiction and speculative fiction (including Dennis Potter’s Cold Lazarus) have highlighted the danger of instant populist democracy. We see glimpses of this already in the number of polls conducted on subjects as diverse as cricket, cars and politics.

The opening of the “Charter for Knowledge Societies” of the IAMCR could be read as a manifesto for Wikileaks. Does that make free access to information a positive or a negative principle to pursue? What are the implications for privacy? Why are the “conversations” of political leaders more in the public interest to disclose interesting than those of industrial leaders, who arguably have more influence on our lives? Is it because, as Browne (Browne, M. 1997, “The field of information policy: 1. Fundamental concepts”, Journal of information science, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 261-275) suggests governments continue to operate with a plethora of overlapping and disorganized policies, while companies and corporations have managed to have their interests protected by copyright and other laws. The recent iinet case in Australia ¬– as with the French (p. 62) and American (p. 68) cases referred to by Dearnley and Feather (2001. Information policy. In The wired world: an introduction to the theory and practice of the information society (pp. 60-93). London: Library Association) – demonstrates that these large companies may have met their match in the world wide web. Or is it because Freedom of Information has created the “right to know” and the technology has created an immediacy of access (legal or illegal) to such a vast amount of information that governments aren’t yet sure of the security implications of the information and certainly don’t have the time to assess it all. Given what Dearnley and Feather (2001, p. 67) say about freedom of information legislation in the USA, one wonders how that government can make the threats that is has allegedly made about the actions of Wikileaks.

The third point is that leaving the provision of knowledge “to the market” can lead to a continuing or new digital divide. This is part of the political debate in Australia at the moment over broadband.

The implication is that libraries have a significant role to play in providing access to a range of information that promotes the public good through the seeking and imparting of information. Libraries will no longer just be repositories or terminals of information, they will be the place where information is generated and from which it is disseminated. They also have an important role to play in the monitoring, critiquing and advocating of information.

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Will Richardson

Will Richardson
Change Agent
Published Online: October 11, 2010
Published in Print: October 12, 2010, as Change Agent
http://www.edweek.org/tsb/articles/2010/10/12/01richardson.h04.html?cmp=clp-edweek


I found Will Richardson’s interview very challenging. I have, as I said above, used digital technology as a tool. I have eschewed social networking for employment and philosophical reasons and I have only a small and disorganized online profile. This is because most of my writing continues to be aimed at the print medium. My blog is largely anonymous and concerned with University studies.

I can see Richardson’s point but I need to ask how one fits in creating this online presence and joining learning or professional networks with the expanding demands that digital communications have placed upon our time.

I find it very frustrating that I cannot find suitable resources on the web for different ages and subjects that I teach or support but by the time I have exhausted that search I don’t feel that I have the time to create what is required. Even with Moodle these tend to end up “works-in-progress” rather than finished products.

I also see that Richardson supports teaching hypertext. There was a time when it was suggested that all students should learn a computer language as their second language, just as there was (and in some places, continues to be) an insistence on students learning or attempting to learn touch typing. Just as knowing Basic, Pascal and even machine language is no longer central to being able to use a computer, I wonder whether hypertext will also become superfluous to the effective use of computers for creative purposes.

Apart from universal applications such as email, desktop publishing, marking spreadsheets and school databases, teachers are most likely to become competent if nor masters at specialist software related to their domain: art, photography, CAD, music and so on. Such programs provide web accessibility, which makes them useful for students to share, compare and evaluate the work of others and, in turn, to display their own work. However, their main working environment is based on individual machines.

Finally, schools face or have created their own series of obstacles to e-learning, as any teacher who has tried to log on a Year 3 or 4 class to the school intranet, let alone allow them access to the wide world of the internet knows that we are a long way from reproducing the social experience of Web 2.0 outside school or making digital learning a seamless part of the school day.

Web 2.0

Roll on the NBN. I’ve just viewed the YouTube clip Web 2.0 The Machine is Us/ing Us, which stopped to reload every fifteen to thirty seconds or so. I was a bit overwhelmed by the html xml section, concerned that I may have to know these terms. Then I realized that the message was exactly the opposite. Now, I don’t need to know a programming language to create with a computer. It’s a bit like the old Word .rtf versus .doc or even the difference between DOS and the Mac GUI interface. As Apple said in their Macintosh ads at the time, the PC had been sent to school to think like a human. No special accolades for Apple here. They have long bought, borrowed or stolen some of the best ideas and marketed them effectively. However, there is an interesting corollary in Web 2.0, which I learnt from the clip. It is that, indeed, computers are learning from us and from the links we forge between different material.

I also appreciated the reminder that Web 2.0 isn’t just about blogs and wikis. Using Diigo to prepare, annotate and share web pages for my students is Web 2.0 in practice. I have always thought of the computer as a tool rather than a recreation source or a form of social media. If it allows me to do something more efficiently, effectively, or both, then it is worth using. If it adds time to a task or requires more understanding on my part or that of my students then it is possibly not the better alternative. This may just have to do with my limited knowledge, my age, learning style or possibly the limited time I have to play around with things and the capacity of the web to use up all the time that you can give it.

Schools as Organisations

The school as an organisation

I’ve been thinking about how organisational theory might help to explain and address possible sources of disagreement and conflict within a school.

While a school may use many terms to describe its set of relationships, it is an organisation – a system of relationships and influences that combine to create structures and networks. The school effectiveness movement sees schools as examples of a rational open systems model. This makes it easy to view the educational process as one of value adding to the raw material of the input. This value-added aspect is what MySchool and the resultant league tables are concerned with. This approach emphasizes formalized social structure and relatively specific goals as well as the effective use of resources and the structural interrelationship of parts of the organisation (Bennett, 2001, p.99).

This type of organisation emphasises detailed job specifications, uniform procedures and consistency. Job descriptions define the lines of accountability and control that govern the work. These descriptions are important to the structuring of work in the organisation. These structures are fixed and only change as the result of specific decisions by those who control them. Those in management are overseers. Two relevant elements of this type of system are:

1) management has a responsibility to reduce the impact of change and upheaval so that they do not interfere with the basic task of the organisation’s members
2) each part of the organisation needs to be kept informed of things that are happening elsewhere that might affect its work.

For example, the management team may try to shelter their staff from the turbulence of issues such as changing enrolment numbers, the effects of the GFC, Naplan and MySchool, while keeping them as informed as was deemed appropriate. However, being informed is not the same as being consulted. The school executive may effectively use “deep coping” strategies such as re-staffing, restructuring and redesigning roles to deal with many of the changes. While some structural changes and new initiatives are introduced with a deliberate process of consultation, other learning programs associated with the structural changes may be altered without mutually agreed plans and no parameters for evaluation.

By comparison, organic views of the school organisation see them as being made up of members rather than tasks and therefore capable of developing a life of their own (Bennett, 2001, p. 100). In this view, the organisation is viewed as having the ability to adapt and grow as needs arise, without having to be changed by management decision.

In my view, the problem with schools is that the class teachers see themselves as part of an organic system, while the structures within which they operate and the expectations placed upon them are more mechanistic. One promotes a relational and nurturing approach, the other focuses on accountability and measurable outcomes. One sees the members as being able to devise and implement solutions to problems (using their skills, training and experience), the other sees management as the source of solutions.

In reality, a person’s place in the organisation defines their role and sphere of influence. Their significance is defined by their relationships with colleagues and the areas in which they are able to make decisions. In this regard, the members of the organisation are not equals. This inequality is an expression of the power that may be exercised by members. This power depends on two things. Firstly, the importance of the individual to the issue under consideration and the decision that has to be made. Secondly, the amount of individual discretion or freedom to act in response to decisions. Further, the power disparity between individuals is a major influence in shaping and defining the way that relationships develop within the organisation.

This power disparity leads non-managers to dismiss the legitimacy of some sources of power such as economic power (or power of dismissal). It may also determine whether a response to change is merely compliance and not full commitment. This is significant in the life of an organisation. Staff willingness and staff initiative has been identified as a factor that leads to successful implementation of change. This has been demonstrated to contribute to school improvement or school effectiveness or teacher effectiveness.

Power sharing is critical to securing staff willingness and initiative and crucial to stabilizing the change after implementation. In the effective schools scenario “the staff is given a considerable amount of responsibility and authority in determining the exact means by which they address the problem of increasing academic performance. This includes giving staffs more authority over curricular and instructional decisions and allocation of building resources” (Purkey and Smith, 1985, p. 358). However, empowerment tends to occur after the major decisions are made a rather than before.

One suggestion to promote stability and empowerment is the Collaborative School Management Cycle (Caldwell and Spinks, 1988). In this the policy group (principal, senior staff and Board) form the policy group, while teachers create programs to support the school activities associated with learning and teaching. The policy group is responsible for goal setting, needs identification, policy making, budgeting and evaluation programs. The program group takes responsibility for planning, budgeting, implementing and evaluating. With contentious issues, where there is disagreement on current practice among staff, it is recommended that a working party be appointed to prepare options for consideration by the policy group.

However, in the case of a disputed hypothetical program the policy group may dictate to the program group how a particular learning program will be designed and implemented. The withdrawal of discretion or authority from the program group by the policy group (teaching staff) may lead to resentment. The exercise of power by the policy group to ensure compliance and stifle debate may lead to feelings of impotence and devaluation. This power imbalance has the potential to weaken initiative and sustain instability. This works against the principle that “the potential of an organisation is realized through its people’s enthusiasm resourcefulness and participation” (Streeton Primary School, 2000).

References

Bennett, N. 2001, Power, structure and culture: an organisational view of school effectiveness and school improvement. In Harris, A. & Bennett, N. (eds) School effectiveness and school improvement: alternate perspectives. Continuum: London, pp. 89-122

Caldwell, B. J. and Spinks, J. M. 1988. The Self-Managing School. London: Falmer Press.

Purkey, S. C., & Smith, M. S. (1985). School reform: The district policy implications of the effective schools literature. Elementary School Journal, 85(3), pp. 353-389.

Streeton Primary School. 2000, The 12 quality principles. In Q is for quality: continuous improvement in schools through quality management and quality learning (pp. 12-24). Yallambie, Vic.: Streeton Primary School.

Monday, November 15, 2010

David Putnam: Information Literacy The Key to Learning

This is quote from David Putman, Academy Award-winning film producer of movies such as Midnight Express, Chariots of Fire, The Killing Fields and The Mission, who is now now a member of the British House of Lords and advocate for educational change.

In an interview on ABC's Latline on Monday November 15th, 2010, David Putman said, "The most important thing I think teachers can do for young people is to make them inquiring, is to ensure that they know how to gather information, that they check information and they take their information from a multiplicity of sources.

If you can get a child to do that and then become interested in the whole process of information gathering, you're halfway towards becoming a learner. And once you're a learner, you're a learner for life. That's certainly been my experience."

What a great description of the nature and effect of information literacy.

He went on to say, "I think that children are getting better and better at gathering information. The problem is that for people of my age and indeed a good deal younger, we get kind of disturbed by the way in which children gather information. And I think it's us, it's my generation and teachers of my generation or in their 40s, 50s, 60s who have got to in a way close that gap with kids, because if kids begin to think - young people begin to think that education has nothing to do with the way their lives are and the way in which they live their lives, they will blame education; they won't blame themselves; they'll blame education.

And my greatest single fear for education is there's a kind of gap that's growing between the way that young people see themselves and the way in which they kind of learn and the way that teachers would like to teach.

Teachers have got to find a way of closing that gap and of meeting young people halfway in terms of using the tools that they use and using the language indeed that they use. We can't, I don't think, sit in some ivory tower and expect young people to come to us. That's just not gonna happen. We must find a way of meeting them halfway."

Read the complete transcript or watch the video at: http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2010/s3067187.htm

Thursday, October 28, 2010

ETL 501 Assignment 2 Feedback

Here is a summary of the marker's comments and some observations from me about Assignment 2. I achieved what I would describe as a respectable pass. I did better with Assignment 1, for those interested. This was marked by James Herring, so it may prove a good guide. I have no quibble with James' comments or marks and I am not seeking to justify my work (however it might seem), but to both reflect on the feedback and provide assistance for others who are yet to undertake this course and assignment.

Before I relate some specific shortcomings, it appears that I made two major mistakes.

In the Pathfinder itself, my annotations had too much information ABOUT the resource and not enough information about how to use them. I don't know that I recall that being clearly explained as the role of the annotations. It may well have been in a podcast or a reading that I missed (there were one or two that I couldn't get to via CSU library) but I felt that my annotations followed the prescriptions given by Lamb and Johnson. The annotations should have included IL directions. I included these in the front page of the Pathfinder as part of a scaffold based on an IL model.

In the critical analysis of what was learned from the process of constructing the pathfinder, I failed to analyse my learning and research process. I thought that the Pathfinder was the evidence of my learning and research and (as you can't refer to yourself) referred to aspects of the Pathfinder and analysed them as examples of my learning.

So the lesson is, from the first time you start experimenting with the search engine, keep a record of what you do, good and bad, and include an analysis of this in the assignment. For me, searching for websites is an automatic skill that I have been developing for some time. I had selected the resources and put the Pathfinder together well before I began the analysis and found it hard to recall the detail of the process apart from one or two highlights.

The difficulty was containing the resources to the specified 15. I think that I'm pretty good at that but I also know that it takes a long time – even longer now that the course has introduced me to so many new search engines. I have learnt some new things such as how to have quick access to most of these search engines through the search box in my web browser toolbar. Should I have included that?

Anyway, some specifics.

1. I didn't reference the class for which I designed the Pathfinder. I named it by NSW Stage and described the make-up of the class. I'm not sure what it means to reference the class. It would be worth finding out.

2. I failed to establish the learning needs. I didn't refer to outcomes but I did specify the topic, type of task and assessment and needs such as "choice" and "access to primary sources".

3. I didn't compare the search engines. In fact I did include some detailed observations about the strengths and weaknesses of the search engines and them took them out to keep under the word limit.

4. I thought that the aim was to evaluate the websites for their usefulness for the students, but I should have evaluated my search strategy and use of the web evaluation criteria from Assignment 1. (It makes so much sense when I write it now). Except that James says, less on source evaluation and more about my search strategy.

5. One of the times that I did discuss something new that I had learned doing this task, I talked about using Advanced Google to locate copy-right free images (they're referred to as reusable images). I explained what I had learned about the importance of eye candy for teenagers. James said that this was discussing the pathfinder, not my learning.

6. I included a quote from Johnson and Lamb about what annotations should do. It didn't include IL. James thought that I should have included this. Once again, I shared what I had learned from Johnson and Lamb but this wasn't seen as my learning.

7. James said that I needed to include references on searching and search engines.

Finally, as always, a reference list that might prove useful.

References

Australian Schools Library Association. (2004). Standards of professional excellence for teacher librarians. Retrieved from: http://www.asla.org.au/policy/standards.htm

Schools Library Association of South Australia. (2008). http://www.slasa.asn.au/Advocacy/rolestatement.html

Brown, C.A. (2008). Building Rubrics: A step-by-step process. In Library media connection. Limworth Publishing Inc., January, 16-18

Focus on inquiry: a teacher’s guide to implementing inquiry-based learning. (2004). PDF version retrieved from the Alberta Learning Web site: http://www.learning.gov.ab.ca/k_12/curriculum/bySubject/focusoninquiry.pdfEdmonton, Alberta: Alberta Learning. Learning and Teaching Resources Branch.

Gross, M., Sleap, B. and Pretorius, M. (1999). Gifted students in secondary schools: Differentiating the curriculum. University of New South Wales, Sydney: Gerric

Hague, C. and Payton, S. (2010). Digital literacy across the curriculum. Futurelab. Retrieved from www.futurelab.org.uk/projects/digital-participation

Johnson, L. and Lamb, A. (2007). Evaluating internet resources. In Teacher tap: Professional development resources for educators and librarians. Retrieved from: http://eduscapes.com/tap/topic32.htm

Johnson, L. and Lamb, A. (2006-2010). Pathfinders. In Electronic materials for children and young adults. Retrieved from http://eduscapes.com/earth/informational/path3.html

Kuhlthau, C. (1993). Seeking Meaning: A process approach to library skills instruction. Norwood, N.J.: Ablex.

Kuntz, K. (2003). Pathfinders: Helping student find paths to information, In Multimedia Schools, 10(3). Retrieved from http://www.infotoday.com/MMSchools/may03/kuntz.shtml

McKenzie, J. (1997). Deep thinking and deep reading in an age of info-glut, info-garbage, info-glitz and info-glimmer. In From now on: The educational technology journal, 6(6), March.

McNicholas, C. and Todd Ross J. (1996). New kids on the block: is it worth the investment? Scan, 15(4), November, 40-42.

Nielsen, J. (2005). Usability of websites for teenagers. On Alertbox, January 31. Retrieved from: http://www.useit.com/alertbox/teenagers.html

Nielsen, J. (2010). Scrolling and Attention. On Alertbox, March 22. Retrieved from: http://www.useit.com/alertbox/scrolling-attention.html

Sizer, T. Essential Questions. Retrieved from http://www.colegiobolivar.edu.co/apenglish/ces_essential_questions.

Valenza, J. (2008). Top ten reasons why your next pathfinder should be a wiki. Retrieved from: http://informationfluency.wikispaces.com/Ten+reasons+why+your+next+pathfinder+should+be+a+wiki

ETL 501 Assignment 1 Feedback

It seems, dear readers, that some people have been uncovering my credentials. Let me assure whomever it may concern that any previous academic experience means little when it comes to the MTL course. It is a level playing field, if ever there was. Here is a belated report on ETL 501 Assignment 1.

1. Don't forget to include the two website criteria in your bibliography. (Obvious isn't it). I chose WWW Cyberguide rating for content evaluation by McLachlan and Criteria for website evaluation by Johnson and Lamb.

2. In your critical examination, include some rank or comment about which criteria are the more important.

3. I only discussed some of the criteria (word limit) that I thought needed further work. I needed to mention and comment briefly on the other criteria and the evaluation tool/model as a whole. Do they cover all the areas that are important to cover? Why is or isn't each tool a valid set of criteria for a TL to use.

4. Because I thought that there were inadequacies in The Cyberguide, I added a couple of criteria. My understanding of the assignment was that this was acceptable and that this set [revised] of criteria should be used in part 2. However, I was criticised for using these extra criteria.Perhaps that's a bit strong. The comment was, "If you are going beyond the designated set of criteria you need to state that you are doing so and why you feel that it is important to do so.

5. I ran out of words or word limit and didn't address all four websites in equal depth and specific references to the criteria.

6. It's important to refer to the needs of your chosen student group and the usefulness of the website for them. You should also refer to the usefulness of the tools for the TL is making that judgement.

Finally, here is my reference list (minus the McLachlan Cyberguide).

References

Bomar, S. (2010) The annotated bibliography: A schoolwide instructional framework for evaluating sources. In Knowledge Quest Volume 38 No. 3 January/February pp. 72-75 American Library Association. Retrieved from CSU Library.

Brown, J., Hickey, K., and Pozen, V. (2002 revision). Methods of evaluation. In An educators’ guide to credibility and web evaluation. Retrieved from http://www.ed.uiuc.edu/wp/credibility/

Gaffney, M. (2010). Enhancing teachers’ take-up of digital content: Factors and design principles in technology adoption. Education Services Australia.
Standards of professional excellence for teacher librarians. Australian School Library Association. Retrieved from: www.asla.org.au/policy/standards.htm

Hague, C. and Payton, S. (2010). Digital literacy across the curriculum. Futurelab. Retrieved from www.futurelab.org.uk

Herring, J.E. (2004). The internet. In The internet and information skills: a guide for teachers and school librarians. London: Facet

Hughes-Hassell, S. and Mancall, J. (2005). Collection management for youth: Responding to the needs of learners. ALA Editions. Retrieved from CSU EBook library.

Johnson, L. and Lamb, A. (2007). Evaluating internet resources. In Teacher tap: Professional development resources for educators and librarians. Retrieved from: http://eduscapes.com/tap/topic32.htm

Kennedy, J. (2005). A collection development policy for digital information resources. In The Australian Library Journal. April 2005. Retrieved from: http://alia.org.au/publishing/alj/54.3/full.text/kennedy.html

Kennedy, J. (2006). Collection management: A concise introduction. Wagga Wagga: Charles Sturt University Centre for Information Studies

Latham, B., & Poe. J. (2008). Evaluation and selection of new format materials: electronic resources. In J.R. Kennedy, L Vardaman, & G.B. McCabe (Eds.), Our new public, a changing clientele: bewildering issues or new challenges for managing libraries (pp. 257-265). Westport, Conn.: Libraries Unlimited.

Naidu, S. (2005) Evaluating the Usability of Educational Websites for Children. In Usability News. Vol. 7(2) July. Retrieved from http://psychology.wichita.edu/newsurl/usabilitynews/72/children_internet.asp

Nielsen, J. (2005). Usability of websites for teenagers. January 31st. Retrieved from: Jakob Nielsen’s Alertbox http://www.useit.com/alertbox/teenagers.html

Osborne, H. (2000). In Other Words... Assessing Readability. . .Rules for Playing the Numbers Game. In Boston Globe's On Call Magazine, December Retrieved from: http://www.healthliteracy.com/article.asp?PageID=3806

Pfoeffer, P. (2002). Web usability and children: Current research and implications for information professionals. In Orana. July. pp. 11 to 13
Retrieved from: http://search.informit.com.au.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/fullText;dn=119869;res=AEIPT

Shrock, K. (2002). The ABCs of Web Site Evaluation. Retrieved from http://school.discoveryeducation.com/schrockguide/eval.html
South Regional Educational Board: SREB (2010). Criteria for evaluating web sites. Retrieved from http://www.evalutech.sreb.org/criteria/web.asp